I’ve spilled the tea on the negative effects of over-tourism in small-town America in “Why Visiting Small Towns in NorCal is a No-Go for 2025“. But let’s be clear—this wasn’t a “locals only” sign hanging in digital form.
Small towns can absolutely benefit from tourism — when it’s done right. In fact, many of us rely on it. We want folks to come enjoy our farmers markets, our festivals, our wildflower-lined trails.
We just don’t want to lose ourselves or our charm in the process.
So here’s the follow-up no one asked for but everyone needs: protecting small town charm while inviting tourism.
Set the Pace with Smart Boundaries
One term that keeps coming up is environmental gentrification—where the “clean-up” efforts meant to protect nature end up driving up housing costs and kicking locals out.
It’s like giving your house a fresh coat of paint but selling it to a stranger before your kids get home from school.
And it’s not just the homes—community character takes a hit too. Festivals shift to appeal to tourists. Longtime events get rebranded. Towns start to feel like a copy of themselves, made for the ‘Gram instead of the locals.
The Solution
Think of the town like your living room—you’re happy to have guests, but not if they stomp on your rug in muddy boots and leave with your last LaCroix.
Limit tourism:
Establish visitor caps for peak times or environmentally sensitive areas.
Encourage off-season travel:
“Come back in October” isn’t shade—it’s sustainability.
Keep Housing for the People Who Actually Live Here
You know what’s worse than tourists blocking Purdon bridge to take a picture? Not having a place to live because the house you used to rent monthly is now $325 a night on Airbnb.
In Sedona, Arizona, locals are getting priced out. Evictions are rising. Schools and businesses are struggling to hire because workers literally can’t afford to live there anymore. And if they do, they’re commuting from hours away.
Short-term rentals are turning full-time communities into part-time backdrops for travel influencers.
The Solution
Implement short-term rental regulations:
Cap the number of days properties can be rented out, or require licensing for STRs. Consider vacancy taxes for second homes that sit empty most of the year.
This will incentivize long-term rentals over vacation homes because, If you’re gonna hoard houses, you should at least contribute to the community.
Help locals stay local:
Create housing initiatives specifically for local workers and families.
Promote Local Over Chain
The more a town leans into the tourist economy, the more it morphs into a stage set.
Local shops that used to sell essentials start hawking dreamcatcher keychains and $11 coffees. And suddenly, the quirky, culture-rich town you grew up in feels more like a pop-up theme park with a gift shop on every corner.
Tourism brings in thousands of visitors yearly—but also traffic jams, wildlife scares, and a whole lot of noise leaving local residents fighting for their peace.
The Solution
Keep it local:
Direct visitors to mom-and-pop shops, community-owned cafés, and handmade goods.
Protect the peace:
Noise ordinances, traffic limits, visitor caps—it’s not about being unwelcoming, it’s about being sustainable.
Local VIPs:
Host “local days” at festivals to make sure residents still feel like VIPs in their own town.
Build Infrastructure Before the Tour Buses Arrive
Infrastructure just isn’t built for the kind of foot traffic from tourists—and it’s not just in California. Many small towns get overrun without the proper funding to support the influx of tourism. This means overflowing trash cans, potholes for days, insufficient public restrooms and water systems crying for help.
The Solution
Invest in infrastructure:
More restrooms.
Adequate parking spaces.
Up to date trail signage.
Plenty of emergency access.
It’s not glamorous, but it’s vital in preserving the town.
Make Locals Part of the Tourism Conversation
The best tourism strategies don’t come from outside developers. They come from the people who live, work, raise kids, and walk their dogs here.
Invite residents to:
Serve on tourism committees
Help craft messaging
Suggest what not to promote (e.g., overused trails, sacred spaces, or residential neighborhoods)
Tourism doesn’t have to be an invasion. It can be an invitation—to appreciate without exploiting, to visit without overtaking, and to support without steamrolling.
So yes, hang your “Welcome!” signs. But hang them next to a community calendar, a renter’s rights poster, and maybe a reminder that not all who wander are mindful—but they could be.
Subscribe to the blog for more community stories, small-town strategies, and the occasional rant.
What’s your take? Drop it below!